Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Eskimo icon should be renamed to Inuit #893

Open
maqloner opened this issue Apr 23, 2022 · 7 comments · May be fixed by #894
Open

Eskimo icon should be renamed to Inuit #893

maqloner opened this issue Apr 23, 2022 · 7 comments · May be fixed by #894

Comments

@maqloner
Copy link

The word Eskimo is an offensive term that has been used historically to describe the Inuit throughout their homeland, Inuit Nunangat, in the arctic regions of Alaska, Greenland and Canada, as well as the Yupik of Alaska and northeastern Russia, and the Inupiat of Alaska.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eskimo#Usage

@highnrgappalachian
Copy link

No. And posting a wikipedia article does not qualify as a reputable source of anything. Begone.

@R2robot
Copy link

R2robot commented May 1, 2022

No. And posting a wikipedia article does not qualify as a reputable source of anything. Begone.

You don't understand how wikipedia works. Follow the footnotes for the sources.

In Canada and Greenland, and to a certain extent in Alaska, the term Eskimo is predominantly seen as offensive and has been widely replaced by the term Inuit[[26]][[37]][[38]][[44]]...

4 of them on that part of the sentence that provide a background on the statement being made:

OP's request is valid and should be considered.

aloisdg added a commit to aloisdg/icons that referenced this issue May 3, 2022
@aloisdg aloisdg linked a pull request May 3, 2022 that will close this issue
@Zaphodious
Copy link

This is not entirely correct. Many in the Alaskan Yupik etc communities do not class themselves as "Innuit", they use the word "Eskimo" and say that Innuits are natives further to the North.

@aloisdg
Copy link

aloisdg commented Aug 15, 2022

The wikipedia page shared above supports @Zaphodious commment:

This has resulted in a trend whereby some Canadians and Americans believe that they should use Inuit even for Yupik who are non-Inuit.[47]

@R2robot
Copy link

R2robot commented Aug 15, 2022

The wikipedia page shared above supports @Zaphodious commment:

This has resulted in a trend whereby some Canadians and Americans believe that they should use Inuit even for Yupik who are non-Inuit.[47]

From that same source...

The change reflects the pushback against the word Eskimo in Alaska in recent years — plus the fact that the term doesn't encompass all the many different groups of indigenous people here. Especially among younger Alaska Natives, people have been shifting away from the term.

"When we were labeled Eskimos, that labeled us as less than human to white Americans," said Ronald H. Brower Sr., an instructor at the Alaska Native Language Center at the University of Alaska Fairbanks. He refers to himself as an Inuk — which most people call Inupiaq — and grew up in Barrow. "It is my hope that this change will bring a more positive relationship between the U.S. government and the aboriginal people in the U.S., especially with Inuk and Athabascans."

So the original point was to remove the term 'eskimo' which was the right thing.

Now if you feel that each individual ethnic group from the region should have their own copy of the icon/name combo, that's a different issue/request.

This thread should probably be locked.

@aloisdg
Copy link

aloisdg commented Aug 16, 2022

Now if you feel that each individual ethnic group from the region should have their own copy of the icon/name combo, that's a different issue/request.

That could be nice if there is a need for it.

As far as this issue goes I would still go for inuit instead of eskimo (and so the PR stands: #894), but I think it is important to acknowledge that inuit is not a one-size-fits-all. Btw ethnologists still use on eskimo:

image

Eskimo-Aleut

Many individuals who would have historically been referred to as "Eskimo" find that term offensive, and/or forced upon them in a colonial way; "Inuit" is now a common autonym for a large sub-group of these people.[17][18][19][20] The word "Inuit" (varying forms Iñupiat, Inuvialuit, Inughuit, etc.), however, is an ancient self-referential to a group of peoples which includes at most the Iñupiat of northern Alaska, the four broad groups of Inuit in Canada, and the Greenlandic Inuit. This usage has long been employed to the exclusion of other, closely related groups (e.g. Yupik, Aleut).[21][22][23][24] Therefore, the Aleut (Unangan) and Yupik peoples (Alutiiq/Sugpiaq, Central Yup'ik, Siberian Yupik), who live in Alaska and Siberia, at least at an individual and local level, generally do not self-identify as "Inuit".[21]

Eskimo has a mainly pejorative exonym should be removed as far as I my own understanding goes. Could we keep inuit as a "better" solution, but maybe tag it with Aleut and Yupik for inclusion?

Note that I have no expertise whatsoever in ethnology and is not related in any way with people from those ethnics. My opinions are just those of a random dev with Wikipedia.

@aloisdg
Copy link

aloisdg commented Aug 16, 2022

@Delapouite There is a call for locking this thread.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

5 participants